EU review of Organic Regulation: Straight bananas, euro-sausages and now... dilute organics?
PRESS RELEASE 02/16/2006 (version 1) Categories: GMO | Health | Press Releases 2006 | Downloads and other links
Peter Melchett, Soil Association policy director, today responds to the proposed revision of the EU Council regulation. A proposed revision of the EU Council regulation [1] governing organic food and farming threatens: – To ride rough-shod over regional and local distinctiveness; – Would allow GM contamination that would risk nearly one in a hundred mouthfuls of organic food being GM; – And would obscure the local origins of organic food by imposing an EU organic logo or generic ‘EU-Organic’ label on all organic food. It would also concentrate power in the hands of the EU Commission. Peter Melchett, policy director said, "This draft revision runs completely counter to the spirit of the pioneers of the organic movement, which grew from the grassroots, prioritising local distinctiveness, care for the environment and animal welfare. [2] "In contrast, the Commission’s draft organic regulation mimics the agribusiness model of globally competitive, freely traded commodity production Proposing that organic food standards should allow routine contamination with GM might please Monsanto, but flies in the face of the widespread public opposition across all EU Member States to this controversial and risky technology. [3] "There’s no doubt that the regulation needed bringing up to date, given the huge surge in public support and market growth since the original was drafted in 1991. But imposing a meaningless, generic ‘EU-Organic’ [4] label will put the Commission into conflict with those who could be its strongest supporters. Consumers want to buy locally sourced organic sausages supporting Norfolk, Cumberland, or Schleswig-Holstein producers not some anonymous ‘Euro-organic sausage'." Taken as a whole, these draft proposals risk a corporate take-over of the organic sector, with all the dire consequences that we have already seen in the USA .[5] Unless the Commission takes notice of the concerns of the Soil Association and other European and international organic bodies, this draft regulation threatens to provoke opposition and disbelief comparable only to the infamous spoof headlines about, ‘EU demands straight bananas’ . Soil Association’s key concerns on the draft revised Regulation: · Article 3 suggests economic viability of a production system rather than the interests of human health or environmental sustainability as the criteria for judging its acceptability. It also sets the weak goal for organic production of only minimising negative effects on the environment rather than delivering positive environmental outcomes. · Article 4 omits any reference to local supply and distribution. · Article 7 would allow routine GM contamination of organic products up to 0.9%, in line with the desire of the US Government and GM companies to see all our food contaminated with GM. · Article 18 forces every organic product to carry an EU logo or to say it is 'EU-organic', obscuring local origin and undermining consumers' ability to choose local food. · Articles 20 and 24 appear to be aimed at restricting what organic farmers and suppliers can tell consumers, especially if their standards are higher than the EU minimum. · Article 31 gives the Commission increased powers similar to those it exercises with the disastrous GM legislation, where it can override the majority opinion of the member states. Ends For media enquiries contact the Soil Association press office press@soilassociation.org / 0117 914 2448 Notes to editors: 1. The Soil Association’s concerns have been submitted as a formal response to the Defra consultation on Proposal for a Council Regulation replacing Council Regulation 2092/91 on Organic Production. 2. The biggest growth area for organic food is via direct sales, such as vegetables. Box schemes and farmers‘ markets, sales grew by 16% in this sector over 2004-5 compared to 9% for organic sales in supermarkets. 3. The draft proposal allows for 0.9% adventitious contamination with GM – equivalent to almost one in 100 mouthfuls of organic food being completely GM while still being sold as organic produce. The Soil Association’s legal opinion is that the current regulation requires no use of GM in organic farming and food – and that is certainly what consumers want and expect when they buy organic produce. 4. The draft proposes the use of the EU organic logo or the label 'EU Organic'. The Soil Association has developed its standards over forty years building strong public trust and awareness; the use of 'EU' on locally produced and imported foods will simply confuse consumers while adding no useful information. 5. In the US the powerful corporate food industry lobby has been pushing to dilute organic standards, for example by allowing hitherto banned artificial and industrial chemical ingredients. This would make entering the lucrative organic market easier for the major food processors. top More links Search library with term press releases 2006 Search rest of website with term press releases 2006 top Library documents in Press Releases 2006 category » £17 million Big Lottery Fund grant brings good food, cooking skills, farm visits and food growing to thousands of school children and their families 02/07/2008 » Orgasmic Organic - Valentine's with an eco-twist 02/20/2006 » David Cameron addresses Soil Association’s 60th Anniversary Conference reception 01/05/2006 » A REAL Burns Supper 12/22/2006 » Minister must take action over rising use of farm drugs implicated in new 'superbug' crisis 12/22/2006 » Revised EU regulation threatens to undermine organic sector 12/19/2006 » Relief for organic farmers as GM contamination threat lifted 12/15/2006 » Journalists have been taken for a ride by misreported organic chicken research 12/07/2006 » Soil Association dismayed at Government decision to give GM potato trial go-ahead - "Last thrashings of a dead dinosaur technology" 12/01/2006 » Deep-fried, additive-laden, junk food and bottomless fizzy drinks - ten top restaurant chains ranked for 'healthy' choices 11/30/2006 » Soil Association events from November 2006 11/20/2006 » Thinking of going organic? Dorset event 11/08/2006 » Soil Association press statement on BBC News survey of school meals uptake. 11/06/2006 » Soil Association comment on 'This century is the last century of wild seafood.' 11/03/2006 » Labour's GM contamination 'legally flawed' - as Government’s GM consultation ends 10/20/2006 » Snow White and Mickey Mouse go Organic 10/18/2006 » Five years on from Fast Food Nation, Eric Schlosser reports on 'progress' 10/16/2006 » Soil Association responds to claims that the organisation's organic standards and principles are becoming diluted 10/05/2006 » Soil Association Organic Food Award Winners 2006 10/04/2006 » Farmers’ look to convert as organic market booms 10/02/2006 » Soil Association responds to the government's latest report on pesticides in food 09/26/2006 » Everyone is cottoning on to organic, eco-chic this Christmas as sales set to triple 09/22/2006 » Thinking of going organic? Leicestershire event 09/21/2006 » Thinking of going organic? Cheshire event 09/21/2006 » Soil Association Dinner Lady Jeanette Orrey calls on “fish and chip” mums to stop deliveries 09/19/2006 » Soil Association events from September 2006 09/19/2006 » Jamie Oliver’s crusade for decent school dinners – some schools already beat the targets 09/18/2006 » Organic farming is a key to Miliband's vision of socially just 'one planet living' 09/18/2006 » Supermarket organic 'box schemes' 09/14/2006 » Soil Association - 60 years practising what we preach 09/08/2006 » Soil Association welcomes today's school food announcement 09/04/2006 » Good 'Moos' for the Soil Association's Organic Fortnight (2 - 17 September) 08/31/2006 » Soil Association Scotland responds to government’s Organic Aid Scheme announcement 08/30/2006 » Time is ripe to go organic - Soil Association’s Organic Fortnight 2006: 2 to 17 September 08/30/2006 » Treat yourself to a guilt-free, organic Christmas feast with all the trimmings 08/25/2006 » 'Taking our children for a ride' - new report from the Soil Association and Organix 08/25/2006 » Thinking of going organic? Perth event 08/16/2006 » Soil Association embraces organic aquaculture 08/15/2006 » The Soil Association Organic Food Festival 2006 – 2-3 September 2006, Bristol Harbourside 08/08/2006 » Sign up for the Soil Association Scotland Organic Food Festival in Glasgow 07/25/2006 » Donna Air is the face of the Soil Association’s Organic Fortnight 07/25/2006 » Thinking of going organic? Devon and Gloucestershire events 07/19/2006 » Soil Association position on vaccination to control bird 'flu in domestic poultry and waterfowl - strategic not preventative 07/18/2006 » Soil Association Organic Fortnight - what's on 07/17/2006 » Defra responds to Soil Association demand for strategic use of bird 'flu vaccine 07/11/2006 » Soil Association Scotland's first Organic Food Festival 07/11/2006 » Soil Association events from July 2006 07/07/2006 » Organic Market - growing globally, booming in Britain UK Sales up 30 per cent - averaging extra £7 million a week 07/07/2006 » Soil Association response to John Innes Centre research on nitrogen fixation 06/27/2006 » Scotland’s rural development programme - time for the Government to get real about organic farming 06/21/2006 » Organic bra boosts breast cancer campaign 06/09/2006 » Soil Association School Food Awards to honour food heroes 06/08/2006 » Soil Association calls for a ban on Aspartame after study confirms serious health concerns 06/08/2006 » New research shows success of improved school meals on eve of Government announcement of new standards for school dinners 05/19/2006 » Organic Works – how organic farming is creating more jobs, revitalising rural economies and encouraging younger, happier people into agriculture (Wales) 05/15/2006 » Organic Works – how organic farming is creating more jobs, revitalising rural economies and encouraging younger, happier people into agriculture (UK) 05/15/2006 » Organic Works – how organic farming is creating more jobs, revitalising rural economies and encouraging younger, happier people into agriculture (Scotland) 05/15/2006 » Organic Works – how organic farming is creating more jobs, revitalising rural economies and encouraging younger, happier people into agriculture (Northern Ireland) 05/15/2006 » Soil Association events from May 2006 04/28/2006 » First ever organic beauty product award at the Soil Association Organic Industry Awards 2006 04/20/2006 » Consumers drive up supermarkets' supply of UK, seasonal, organic food 04/20/2006 » Thinking of going organic? 04/11/2006 » Go organic with your Easter eggs 04/10/2006 » Death of wild swan confirms bird flu 04/06/2006 » GM crops contaminate up to 50% of organic maize in Northern Spain 04/05/2006 » Hugh to serve up awards 04/05/2006 » Royal flush of awards for Soil Association 03/31/2006 » Better deal for organic producers 03/29/2006 » Organic fish think tank 03/24/2006 » Unique partnership for sustainable, organic salmon farming 03/24/2006 » Pesticide levels: organic and non-organic compared 03/21/2006 » Free waste audits for Scottish farms 03/13/2006 » Toxic 'cocktail additives' in children's foods 03/08/2006 » School Food Trust - Soil Association Response 03/03/2006 » Another first for organic aquaculture 02/20/2006 » EU review of Organic Regulation: Straight bananas, euro-sausages and now... dilute organics? 02/16/2006 » Scottish report shows increase in indigenous organic produce 02/10/2006 » WTO ruling - "No change to de facto European ban on GMOs" 02/09/2006 » First director for Soil Association Scotland 02/07/2006 » Focus on food during Scottish Environment Week 01/26/2006 » Countdown to world’s first organic Burns Supper 01/19/2006 » Rocket composter reduces waste at star studded climate neutral Soil Association conference 01/04/2006 (: archived document)
Address of this document: http://www.soilassociation.org/web/sa/saweb.nsf/librarytitles/2089E.HTMl
top